Turning Cookie Dough Into Cookies: A Johnny Cash Study


I was talking to my cousin, Katrina, tonight and when I asked her if she was going to Charlie’s Halloween party, she said she wasn’t going because she didn’t want to celebrate “a day of death.” I thought she was joking at first but given her religious beliefs, I figured there was a chance she was serious.
“Are you serious? You’re not gonna go?,” I said.
She said she didn’t want to be a part of a day that was rooted in pagan rituals and possible satan worship. Which I understand — I’m not into rituals either. . . or routines of any kind for that matter, and I’m certainly not into worshiping someone who – from what I’ve seen in movies and cartoons – has had it out for mankind for centuries.
But if we’re going to take a historical perspective on current holidays, December 25th was also a pagan celebration in which the sun god was worshiped. That was until Theodosius made Christianity the official religion of the Roman Empire in 380AD, turning the pagan temples into churches and December 25th into Jesus’ birthday.
But that’s not the point. The point is that Katrina (oh yeah, this is not her real name by the way. her name has been changed to protect her identity and to make sure she will still babysit Magu every once in a while when we leave town) So what I was saying was. . . Katrina was seeing cookie dough when she could have seen cookies. Everything has different forms and the world and how we perceive it is, for a lack of a more cliche phrase, “what you make of it.”
My case study being Johnny Cash. In the last years of his life, Mr. Cash recorded many covers. But the ones that stick out to me are his recordings of Nine Inch Nails’ “Hurt” and Depeche Mode’s “Personal Jesus.” With “Hurt,” Mr. Cash changes the phrase, “I wear this crown of shit” into “I wear this crown of thorns.” A subtle replacement but powerful in its inherent meaning. In his rendition of “Personal Jesus,” a song that originally seems to mock faith and its devotees’ need for a mental crutch, Mr. Cash baptizes and converts the tune into a sincere, personal statement of faith — with no lyric changes whatsoever. But the intent changed. The tone changed. And that was enough to transform everything.
And maybe that’s the point. If we wanted to find faults in anything all the time, we could. But as artists and creative minds, we have a chance to make anything our own. We can make cookie cough into cookies or cookies with a donut hole in the middle or square cookies or whatever. As artists, we are called to challenge the culture, not retreat from it.
-Bla[ke]
“In the absence of light, darkness prevails.” – Hellboy, 2004







